• Build Your Own Box
  • Build Your Own Box
  • Build Your Own Box
  • Build Your Own Box

Build Your Own Box

Use the handy drop-down menu below to create a custom box of your favorite flavors! Select up to 10 different flavors. Each box contains 10 full-size Nightingales. 

Regular price $84.99
Unit price per
Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
  • Woman Owned
  • Clean Label
  • Non-GMO
  • Dye-Free
  • No Artificial Flavors
Home Delivery!

Only The Good Stuff

  • 14% Butterfat Ice Cream
  • No Artificial Flavors or Dyes
  • Fresh Ingredients (Real Fruit!)
  • Handmade Inclusions

FAQ

Find the most frequently asked questions below.
  • Please email us! info@nightingaleicecream.com

  • Orders placed Sunday - Tuesday will typically ship that week and orders placed Wednesday - Saturday will typically ship the following week.

    You'll receive an order confirmation email upon ordering & a shipping confirmation email with tracking information once your order ships. All orders are shipped via 1 or 2 day shipping speeds and are packed in insulated boxes with dry ice packs.

    Holidays & other changes may affect the shipping schedule. If you have any questions about your order or transit times, please email us at info@nightingaleicecream.com.

  • You can currently find Nightingale in thousands of grocery chains and independent markets across the country, including The Fresh Market, Kroger, Ralph’s, Harris Teeter, HEB, and more. To find us near you, please use our handy store finder.

  • Not at this time, but maybe In the future!

  • About Us

    When Belgian chef Xavier came to Richmond, Virginia to open a restaurant, little did he know he’d meet his match in his meticulous and spunky Southern sous chef, Hannah.

    Now the husband and wife team sandwich together their European roots, Southern charm and premium ice cream between freshly baked chewy cookies.

     

Customer Reviews

Based on 1 review
100%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
T
Tonya
Best of the Best Sammies!

These are, by far, the best tasting, quality ice cream "sammies" I have ever eaten!! Pure ice cream heaven. I have two favorites so far: banana pudding and chocolate French roast. Looking forward to trying ALL the flavors. Thanks Nightingale!!