Recreating the childhood classic with sophistication 

Explore our four versatile flavor lines



Our Classics Line of sandwiches are our top sellers. Available year round, they feature universally appealing flavor combinations elevated to the Nightingale standard of quality.

The Classic

Chocolate Brownie Cookie,
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

Cookie Monster

Chocolate Chip Cookie,
Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

Fat Banana

Peanut Butter Cookie, Fresh Banana Ice Cream, Half Dipped In Chocolate

Peaches & Cinnamon

Brown Sugar Cookie,
Peaches & Cinnamon Ice Cream

Chocolate Blackout

Chocolate Brownie Cookie, Chocolate Ice Cream w. Chocolate Cake Pieces + Chocolate Frosting Swirl

Strawberry Shortcake

Brown Sugar Cookie,

Fresh Strawberry Ice Cream

Raspberry white chocolate

Brown Sugar Cookie,

Raspberry Ice Cream w. White Chocolate Chunks

Chocolate French Roast

Chocolate Brownie Cookie,

French Roast Ice Cream 



Our Desserts Line turns familiar post-meal indulgences into craveable treats to enjoy on the go. With flavors ranging from Banana Pudding to Pecan Pie, there's something for everyone.

Brown Sugar Cookie,

Key Lime Ice Cream

Key Lime Pie

Orange Creamsicle

Brown Sugar Cookie,

Orange Ice Cream w. Orange Zest

Pecan Pie

Brown Sugar Cookie,

Pecan Praline Ice Cream

Chocolate Brownie Cookie,

Chocolate Espresso Ice Cream w. Chocolate Chunks

Chocolate Espresso

Banana Pudding

Brown Sugar Cookie,

Fresh Banana Ice Cream, Swirled w. Vanilla Pudding + Vanilla Wafers



The warm, fuzzy feelings that accompany end-of-year festivities are captured in our Holiday Line of flavors. Enjoy with family and friends to make your holiday celebrations extra sweet.



Covered Orange

Chocolate Brownie Cookie, Orange Ice Cream, Half Dipped in Chocolate

Caramel Chai

Brown Sugar Cookie, Chai Ice Cream Swirled w. Dulce de Leche

Chocolate Peppermint Bark

Chocolate Brownie Cookie, Chocolate Ice Cream w. Peppermint + White Chocolate Pieces


The flavors found in our Delicacy Line feature unique and international ingredients. Self-proclaimed foodies or those looking for something a little different will surely enjoy these flavor combinations.


Miso Churro

Cinnamon Brown Sugar Cookie, White Miso Ice Cream w. Churro Pieces


Chocolate Rose'

Brown Sugar Cookie, Strawberry Rose' Ice Cream, Ruby Chocolate Dip



Interested in setting up a wholesale account? 

Click Here for more info.


  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Website by Big Fancy